A Tale of Two Politicians: Malaysians Calling for Azmin and Tajuddin's Resignations

Malaysians have been calling for the metaphorical heads of two prominent politicians, Tajuddin Abdul Rahman and Azmin Ali, after a series of gaffes that left the public seething.

Tajuddin was the former chairman of Prasarana Malaysia Berhad, a GLC which operates the Light Rapid Transit (LRT) system. After the LRT crash near KLCC on 24 May, Tajuddin gave a press conference the next day, which many have described as appalling. He was fired from his position on 26 May. Recently, Tajuddin defended his behaviour at the aforementioned press conference, claiming he was “humiliated” and threatening to sue those who had allegedly “tarnished his reputation.”

Azmin is the current minister of the Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI), the seemingly sole ministry initially responsible for operating the system issuing letters for allowing businesses to operate during the MCO 3.0. Business owners, including SMEs and hotel operations, have complained about problems in obtaining these approval letters, including from technical issues not unlike the ones during the AstraZeneca registrations. This, coupled with reports of non-essential businesses being allowed to operate as well as unclear lockdown SOPs, have led to an online petition calling for Azmin's resignation. As of 4.30 p.m. on 17 Jul, the petition has garnered almost 240,000 signatures.

And May the Odds be Ever in Your Favor: Malaysia's AstraZeneca Vaccine Hubbub

In a bid to both persuade people to vaccinate and not let vaccines go to waste, Malaysia introduced a registration programme separate from its national immunisation plan for those willing to take the AstraZeneca (AZ) vaccine. While not ideal, many have acknowledged that the move may be necessary due to public hesitancy following emerging reports of blood clot risks associated with the vaccine (which, incidentally, is extremely rare—chances of dying due to blood clots as a result of the AZ vaccine is literally one in a million; you have a better chance of being struck by lightning in Subang Jaya by comparison).

Things did not go as smoothly as hoped. The first round of online registration on 2 May for 268,800 slots for the AZ vaccines saw a delayed launch and several website glitches, which was unfortunate albeit not surprising given the novelty of the situation.

However, by the third round on 26 May, this time for 956,609 slots, (the second one on 23 May was opened only to the elderly), these problems seemed to have worsened—applicants were faced with a slew of technical issues including infinite captcha loops, unresponsive website buttons, and repeated submissions of personal details. Bizarrely, some users who failed to register were later sent appointment dates, while others who actually managed have yet to receive an update, compounding the frustration.

In a streak of morbid humour, netizens have likened the mad scramble for AZ vaccine appointments to that of the Hunger Games—the term gained traction in Twitterjaya during the periods when the online registrations were opened, especially during the third round of registrations (see the chart below). Interestingly, the term “RM70 million” has also recently trended, most likely referring to the RM70 million allocated to the country’s national coronavirus vaccination programme for “data integration and appointment system” purposes.

The disastrous registration processes generally coincided with spikes in several Twitter hashtags as well, particularly #KerajaanGagal and #KerajaanBodoh, although the former has trended for other pandemic-related issues, notably during the announcement of yet another movement control order (MCO) on 10 May.

By the PolTracker team, 8 Jun 2021

Here We Go Again: GPS All Set to Win Sarawak Election

Compiled by Poltracker

Covid-19 pandemic and the declaration of Emergency on 12 January have cooled off talks of a snap poll at the national level but not quite in the case of Sarawak.

On 22 January, it was reported that the Sarawak government plans to appeal to the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to lift the emergency order in the state if it can bring the Covid-19 situation to a manageable level. This would then pave way for the state election.

The present state government has a mandate until June while the Emergency order is expected to be in force until 1 August. An election must be held within 60 days of the expiration of the mandate or dissolution of the state assembly. The Emergency (Essential Powers) Ordinance 2021 among others stipulated that general elections, state elections and by-elections, as well as Parliament and State Legislative Assembly sittings, will not be held as long as the emergency is in force.

Sarawak has had good control of the spread of the pandemic with tight border controls and mandatory quarantine of 14 days upon arrival, thereby keeping its cases low. However, in the past month, there has been a surge in cases which have since spread to the longhouses and interior part of the state. Presently at daily three-digit high, it would take some weeks to bring down the numbers again.

A total of 82 state seats are up for grabs at the 12th state election. Gabungan Party Sarawak (GPS) has control of the state with 68 seats. GPS was created post 2018 general election where the Sarawak-based parties withdrew from Barisan Nasional (BN) but remained friendly to them. The opposition bloc has the remaining 14 seats.

GPS, led by Chief Minister Datuk Patinggi Abang Johari Openg who took over the state leadership after the demise of the late Tan Sri Adenan Satem in 2017, has been dishing out aids to the people and businesses since the onset of the pandemic.

To date, its Bantuan Khas Sarawakku Sayang (BKSS) has spent almost RM3 billion to mitigate the impact of Covid-19. The relief from BKSS has been well received and will to a certain extent help to shore up support for GPS which will bode well for the coming election.

The pandemic has also resulted in the state tightening its entry rules. In October last year, the state announced that all election workers and campaigners from outside Sarawak must obtain a work permit from the state Immigration Department before they are allowed entry in the event of a state election. This, to a certain extent, would put a spanner in the opposition machinery. 

The opposition front especially Democratic Action Party (DAP) had in past elections relied on many out of state campaign workers which include polling and counting agents. The outsiders were known to be more vocal and assertive when dealing with issues especially at the polling and counting centres as compared to local election workers, a fact that did not escape Deputy Chief Minister Datuk Amar Douglas Uggah.

Uggah warned Sarawakians that campaign workers from the peninsula are known for their more aggressive or robust behaviour.

“Let us not be cowed by them nor should we imitate them,” he said when announced the work permit requirement.

While there is a movement to take Sarawak out from Malaysia, it is not expected to make any headway for now. Bread and butter for the ordinary man on the street and development of better infrastructure for rural areas remain the issues at hand. 

While the opposition had a good chance of giving GPS a run for its money, had the election been called when Pakatan Harapan (PH) was in power at the Federal level, it would be another uphill battle to wrestle the state.

The opposition has yet to work out the seat allocation between them to avoid contesting against each other. Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) Sarawak has issued an ultimatum to Parti Sarawak Bersatu (PSB) that a deal must be reached by the end of the month. PKR had lost some seats when some assemblymen left the party when the PH government collapsed and has targeted to win six to seven seats at the next election.

PKR state chairman Larry Sng has indicated that the party is willing to negotiate half of their seats identified to be contested in the coming election in the interest of the PH coalition. 

“However, it is unacceptable for us to give away seats which the party had previously won, particularly Batu Lintang and Ba Kelalan,” Sng said. Both the assemblymen for the two seats, See Chee How and Baru Bian, quit PKR in 2020 and have since joined PSB. 

PH Sarawak and DAP Sarawak chairman Chong Chieng Jen said the opposition coalition is willing to negotiate with PSB for the next state election with a ‘3+3+3+1’ formula on the seat allocation between political parties where DAP, PKR and PSB each contest 30 per cent of the constituency seats in the state election, while Parti Amanah Negara (Amanah) would be contesting the remaining 10 per cent of the seats.

As to whether the opposition can retain or increase their current 14 seats in the state assembly, the key lies in striking a deal that would avoid contesting each other.

As for GPS, it is set to retain control of the state once more.

By the PolTracker team, 4 Feb 2021

Second Time's the Charm: Malaysia and the State of Emergency

Compiled by Poltracker

Just 13 days into 2021, the country’s political climate remains turbulent with removal and growing calls for a snap poll from Umno despite the raging Covid-19 pandemic. 

To make things even more interesting, a state of Emergency on 12 January to combat the pandemic. This has resulted in the suspension of Parliament and state assemblies. It will keep things on simmer for now and put an end to any talks of an immediate general election.

Umno delivered a surprise on 5 January when Federal Territories Minister Tan Sri Annuar Musa was removed as secretary-general for Barisan Nasional (BN). Annuar’s ‘crime’ was alleged to be the voice of Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia (Bersatu) in BN.

Days after the removal, Annuar had slammed those in his party for calling for a snap election amid the Covid-19 pandemic.

“Urging for elections when the people and the country are struggling with Covid-19, floods, the economy, clearly reflects not only the irresponsibility, but also the hunger for power and the lack of sensitivity to the people’s suffering. That is not the will of the grassroots,” said the Ketereh MP in his Twitter account.

His comment echoed Umno minister and Rembau MP Khairy Jamaluddin who said any section of Malaysia seeking a general election alongside the Covid-19 pandemic was “selfish” and “irresponsible”, and acknowledged that the group included those from his party.

Umno has been pushing for snap poll for the past few months in both subtle and not so subtle manner. In October last year, it had threatened to pull out of the PN coalition and more recently Umno president Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi had said elections could be held with Standard Operating Procedures (SOP) in place.

"Why are we afraid of holding a general election during the pandemic? More than 30 countries have already done so… Why is Malaysia is so afraid? I think that we're not really scared of Covid-19 but of other things," he said in his opening speech at the Bagan Datuk Umno division meeting on 3 January.

While Annuar has remained supportive of the Perikatan Nasional (PN) government, his fellow MPs Datuk Seri Mohamed Nazri Abdul Aziz of Padang Rengas and Machang MP Datuk Ahmad Jazlan Yaakob have withdrawn their support. 

Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin's government is now left with 109 MPs on its bloc out the current 220 MPs. The Dewan Rakyat is comprised of 222 seats but is currently down to 220 following the deaths of Batu Sapi MP Datuk Liew Vui Keong and Gerik MP Datuk Hasbullah Osman last year.

At 109, the PN government does not have the simple majority support of the Dewan Rakyat.

Umno was scheduled to discuss its ties with Bersatu at its General Assembly at the end of this month but that will put on hold as Kuala Lumpur has been put on MCO until 26 January with probable extension due to the rising number of positive Covid-19 cases.

It is obvious that UMNO is the key component to keeping Muhyiddin’s coalition alive. PN’s government’s legitimacy has been questioned since the Sheraton move last February. More withdrawal of support from UMNO’s MPs will make the government untenable, Emergency or not.

The only thing that remains in Muhyiddin’s favour is the challenge for the opposing MPs to hammer a coalition to form a government until such time it is safe to go to the polls.

By Sharon TAN, KHOR Yu Leng, and the PolTracker team, 18 Jan 2021

Editor’s note on the data chart:

• Following the Emergency announcement, the government regulatory body, Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC), warned netizens to “be polite and courteous” [jaga kesopanan dan kesusilaan: this seems to be taken straight from the Rukun Negara (Malay for the Malaysian declaration of national philosophy), which is generally recited weekly by school students] when expressing opinions online. This carefully worded warning somehow led to Twitter users exposing MCMC past off-colour Tweets, which turned out to be from a previous user from whom they bought their account in an apparent violation of Twitter’s terms and conditions.

• Twitter sentiments on the YDPA appear caught up in problems that users are highlighting for the YDPA’s attention, e.g. complaints about politicians, suggestions to cut their salaries. This means Tweets tagged as a negative sentiment are not actually about the YDPA; it is the issues netizens are urging him to address which are negative. In general, sentiments towards the YDPA are much more favourable compared to sentiments on politicians.

Money, Money, Money: The 2021 Budget

Compiled by PolTracker

Nadirah

Just last week, the Muhyddin administration presented their budget for 2021. Interestingly, Twitterjaya mentions and sentiment appeared less than thrilled, with Tengku Zafrul Aziz, the current Finance Minister, receiving quite a brunt of Malaysian Twitter netizens displeasure.

While criticism of government budgets is a traditional annual event, the air about it feels different for 2020. This year, public disapproval—at least the ones online—seems more visceral than usual, aggravated by the rakyat’s already building frustration due to the coronavirus pandemic as well as the continuous gaffes by the government in response to the recent wave of Covid-19 cases. Public trust in politicians on both divides is tanking, and after the Budget voting fiasco, it’s anyone’s guess how that trust is going to be rebuilt (if it was even there to begin with).

Yu Leng
The Muhyiddin administration is relatively safe until the final budget vote (3rd reading) on 17th December. It won this first hurdle by a walk over! It means that the opposition does not have the strength to topple it. There has been so much chatter in Kuala Lumpur about ruling coalition factions sitting out and even about opposition factions negotiating deals for a unity approach. But the Prime Minister is all powerful in Malaysia’s winner-takes-all political economy.

The “voice vote” and the inexplicable no-vote-silence of major parts of the opposition came as a big surprise yesterday.  Let’s not forget that the underlying mood in Malaysia appears rather negative despite this being seen as a pro-Bumiputera budget. Looking beyond the intellectual chat groups, I was surprised to see how negative is sentiment in Twitter on belanjawan (budget in Malay) and regarding the Minister of Finance. This is another (wider) bubble of opinion but the deteriorating sentiment since the Budget Speech on 6 November is still notable. 

Trumpian politics does point to the big weight of the rural vote while urbanites may be left to whinge on. Those relying on urban votes may feel they sit strong in their niches too. But politicians across the spectrum should not forget there is deep suspicion that double standards (for their benefit) has taken Malaysia from a stellar position in Covid-19-economic mitigation to a plummeting situation; on the back of the free-and-easy approach they all took in the Sabah election in recent months. The obvious Covid-19 SOP exemptions they enjoy are also splashed across social media. The strong wave of Covid-19 cases post-Sabah and the movement restrictions have pulled the rug out from under the rakyat’s feet yet again. Belanjawan/Budget 2021 has to spend wisely to mend all this.

This unprecedentedly awkward budget process will increase distrust in politicians. All politicians will be answering tough questions. The opposition on why so many did not push for a formal count? The PN-BN group about accountability and oversight of Budget spending; to address Malaysia’s chronic untargeted spending problem. The country has been running budget deficits since the Asian Financial Crisis in the late 1990s and even the short-lived Pakatan Harapan administration had a bigger Budget than the Najib administration, and on and on it goes.

Sharon

Instead of allowing people to access their EPF savings, the government should have worked with the banks for an extension of the moratorium for loans. The government as regulators has the ability to make the banks toe the line while the banks are able to withstand the deferred service of loans. Technically, the banks’ are not registering losses but merely deferring profits. A moratorium on the loans would give individuals and businesses a lot of breathing space as they navigate through this difficult climate. As it is many have lost jobs and businesses shuttered, the moratorium would prevent a whole lot of NPLs.

Another case against the EPF withdrawal is RM10,000 would not go very far for most people. Whether it is a one off withdrawal or in 12 instalments, it will not be able to tide much more than three months. What happens after that? As it stands, Malaysians don’t have enough savings in EPF for their retirement. Taking out RM10,000 is a big sum for the lower income earners and would seriously affect their retirement fund.